It’s a bright Saturday morning. The sun is shining, and I’ve just come back from my weekly farmer's market trip. The scent of fresh produce is still lingering in the air, but I’m craving something sweet and spreadable. That’s when I remember my latest obsession—cookie butter. There’s something magical about this creamy concoction that makes it a wonderful addition to so many dishes.
Thinking back, I remember trying it for the first time on a piece of warm toast slathered with butter. The blend of spiced sweetness and the nutty notes of the cookies had me hooked instantly. Fast forward to today, and I can’t wait to share how you can make this indulgent spread from scratch.
To put it simply, cookie butter is a velvety spread made from ground cookies, sugar, and spices. It originated in Belgium and is often compared to peanut butter, though it brings a completely different flavor profile to the table. Unlike nut butters, it's made from crushed cookies, creating a delectable taste that can remind you of a warm hug on a chilly day.
Imagine a rich, gooey spread with hints of cinnamon, a hint of nutmeg, and a sugary sweetness that transports you right back to your childhood. Perfect with pancakes, on a spoon, or even in the center of a cookie, cookie butter adds that extra wow factor to any dish.
To embark on your cookie butter adventure, gather these core ingredients:
10 oz spiced gingersnap cookies (check the notes for alternatives)
½ cup freshly boiled water
½ cup unsalted European-style butter
2 tablespoons lightly packed dark brown sugar
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (a touch of depth)
½ teaspoon ground cinnamon (for added warmth)
⅛ teaspoon fine sea salt
These ingredients create a harmonious blend of flavors, making it difficult to resist snacking directly from the jar.
Making cookie butter is straightforward and can be done in a matter of minutes. The process combines basic baking techniques with a little bit of blending magic. Let’s break it down into digestible steps.
First, you'll need to crush your spiced gingersnap cookies. You can do this by placing them in a ziplock bag and smashing them with a rolling pin or using a food processor for a finer texture. The goal is to get them into crumbs.
In a small saucepan over low heat, melt your European-style butter. It’s crucial to monitor it carefully so that it doesn't brown. You want it just melted, not sizzling. Once melted, remove it from heat and set it aside.
Take a mixing bowl and add your cookie crumbs, dark brown sugar, vanilla extract, and ground cinnamon. Mix these together until they form a cohesive mixture.
Now, the fun part. Gradually stir in the freshly boiled water. This step will help to hydrate the cookie crumbs and bring everything together. Continue to mix until you achieve a smooth consistency.
Once the mixture is cohesive, pour in the melted butter. Mix thoroughly, ensuring the butter is fully incorporated. You may want to enlist a hand mixer for this step if you're aiming for an ultra-smooth texture.
Here comes the delicious part. Before sealing it up, grab a spoon and taste your creation. Adjust sweetness or spice as desired. Remember, it's your cookie butter; make it your own!
Once you’re satisfied, transfer the cookie butter to a jar. Seal tight and let it cool at room temperature.
Ginger Snaps vs. Other Cookies: Feel free to use other cookies like speculoos or even Oreos. Adjust the add-ins like spices and sugars accordingly.
Butter Matters: European-style butter has a higher fat content, lending a richer flavor.
Water Temperature: Using freshly boiled water helps meld the ingredients but be cautious to not splash yourself!
Chilling Makes it Better: Allowing the cookie butter to chill enhances the flavor.
Experiment: Add different spices or chocolate chunks for varied versions!
For best results, keep your cookie butter stored in an airtight container in the fridge. It should last about two weeks, though I doubt it’ll stick around that long!
While this delight isn't exactly healthy food, it’s all about balance. Here's a rough estimate for a two-tablespoon serving:
Remember, indulge occasionally and in moderation!
Spread it on Toast
Nothing beats warm toast topped with cookie butter. Just a generous smear will make your morning blissful.
As a Dip for Fruits
Slice up apples or pears and dip them into cookie butter. The sweet and slightly spiced flavors make for a perfect snack.
Swirl it into Oatmeal
Stirring cookie butter into your morning oats takes breakfast to a whole new level. It’s like dessert for breakfast!
Use in Sandwiches
Why not? Spread cookie butter between slices of whole grain bread, and maybe add banana slices. A delicious twist on peanut butter and jelly.
Drizzle Over Pancakes
Warm pancake stacks become heavenly when drizzled with cookie butter. It melts beautifully and makes every bite a treat.
Speculoos Cookies
A crispy alternative that adds spice and depth. This classic cookie is the original inspiration behind cookie butter.
Peanut Butter Cookies
Swap in peanut butter cookies for a nutty flavor. Just be aware of any allergies!
Oreo Cookies
Crushed Oreos create a cookies-and-cream version. Layer it into desserts for a fun twist.
Choco Chip Cookies
Classic chocolate chip can be a delightful option for a sweeter profile. They blend beautifully to create a creamy treat.
Shortbread Cookies
For a buttery base that complements the spices, shortbread cookies work well. The texture will be slightly different, but still delicious!
Making cookie butter was a delightful experience for me, and I hope this guide inspires you to create your own. Its versatility brings joy to many dishes, making it a kitchen staple. Whether you spread it on toast, blend it into desserts, or enjoy it straight from the jar, cookie butter adds a little sweetness to life.
With each bite, memories of childhood and cozy mornings flood back. The process is simple and rewarding, much like cooking itself. So go ahead, unleash your creativity, and let that cookie butter fly high. Happy spreading!
It’s a bright Saturday morning. The sun is shining, and I’ve just come back from my weekly farmer's market trip. The scent of fresh produce is still lingering in the air, but I’m craving something sweet and spreadable. That’s when I remember my latest obsession—cookie butter. There’s something magical about this creamy concoction that makes it a wonderful addition to so many dishes.
Thinking back, I remember trying it for the first time on a piece of warm toast slathered with butter. The blend of spiced sweetness and the nutty notes of the cookies had me hooked instantly. Fast forward to today, and I can’t wait to share how you can make this indulgent spread from scratch.
Servings 34
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily value may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Ginger Snaps vs. Other Cookies: Feel free to use other cookies like speculoos or even Oreos. Adjust the add-ins like spices and sugars accordingly.
Butter Matters: European-style butter has a higher fat content, lending a richer flavor.
Water Temperature: Using freshly boiled water helps meld the ingredients but be cautious to not splash yourself!
Chilling Makes it Better: Allowing the cookie butter to chill enhances the flavor.
Experiment: Add different spices or chocolate chunks for varied versions!
Lauren Miller is a Maryland-based registered dietitian and the creator of Comfort Food Meals, where she shares easy, nutritious, and heartwarming recipes inspired by her love for comforting, home-cooked meals. With a focus on using wholesome ingredients, Lauren aims to balance indulgence with nutrition in every dish. Her goal is to help others create meals that nourish both body and soul.